The Reading Level of Sports Writing

by Ben Blatt

The last time we played around with sportswriter analytics, we wondered if we could algorithmically determine the author of a column based on his favorite words (we could). For a followup, I decided to look at the readability of different writers. Reading level is a nebulous concept and hard to define precisely, but we have a statistical measure known as the Flesch-Kincaid readability test to give us a rough benchmark. The formula is below:

The output of the test is a single value that can be interpreted as the “grade level” of a piece of writing—i.e. the lowest level at which a writer can be considered accessible. As you can see, the test assigns higher grade scores to writers who have words with lots of syllables and sentences with lots of words. It’s imperfect, but it’s still a good way of assigning a value in an unbiased way.

First, I decided to see how sports writing compared with other sections of the newspaper. I choose the New York Times and compared the reading level of the sports columns to the writing of other sections.

Unsurprisingly, the fields that people follow for fun and that rarely contribute tangibly to society (sports, arts, politics) had the lowest reading level. While I would bet the ranking of sections in other newspapers would be similar, it would be naive to think that the grade levels would be the same for other papers. For example, the New York Post‘s sports section has a Flesch-Kincaid grade level of 7.2.

I performed the test on a variety of sports writers from a variety of publication. Below are the writers I chose; next to the writer’s name is the media outlet from which I took a writing sample.

Looking at this chart, I really don’t see any surprises. Charlie Pierce is known for his smart prose. Whitlock, Leitch, Rovell, Wilbon, and Simmons all bunch together, which makes a rough kind of sense (they’re all popular columnists writing for large, diverse audiences). Tucker Wyatt, a 13-year-old “kid reporter” for Sports Illustrated for Kids, writes at a 7.2 grade level. Sure it would be easy to ridicule him for writing at such a low reading level, but considering he’s probably only in the seventh grade himself and is writing for other kids, that really wouldn’t be fair. Rick Reilly finished out the rankings with a 5.2 grade level.

Before you go drawing any sweeping conclusions, a caveat: The Flesch-Kincaid formula is not perfect. It penalizes writers for using short, punchy sentences and small words. And we’re not talking about the intelligence of a writer (although, for the record, the reading level of my previous HSAC articles checked in at 9.7). We’re talking about the level at which prose is pitched. A writer with a broad following would almost certainly have a lower reading level.

That being said, the lowest reading-level result on any writing sample that I tested came from people I am certain are the dumbest writers on the internet. The folks who left comments at the end of Yahoo! Sports articles wrote at a 3.3 grade level.

Ben Blatt can be contacted at bbblatt@gmail.com.

About these ads
This entry was posted in Baseball, Football, Hockey, Menu. Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to The Reading Level of Sports Writing

  1. kevinmeers says:

    So bold. Nice post Ben.

  2. skbeeasy says:

    You hit the point with this one here. Check out my blog…www.realsportsrealtalk.wordpress.com …I hope its on grade level……

  3. D J says:

    Kind of a shocker that Harvard kids would value big words and long sentences. How does that old bullfighting writer Ernie Hemingway rate on your scale?

  4. Paul C says:

    “The folks who left comments at the end of Yahoo! Sports articles wrote at a 3.3 grade level.”

    That seems a bit high.

  5. LucasG says:

    Is it possible that kevinmeers just posted at a negative grade level? That’s impressive, well done.

  6. marc says:

    Sections we follow for fun, politics, bc it doesn’t contribute to society. Zing.

  7. Csnow says:

    It is hard to comment on this topic with a long sentence full of syllables and words so all I need to say is “GO TUCKER!”.

  8. Pingback: The Reading Level of Sports Writing and Skip Bayless. | gallopingael.net

  9. Pingback: The Tapes: May 25 « TVFury

  10. Lauren Kirk says:

    Just did the calculations for my page program essay and got a 8.7 for a score. I would consider that pretty good for an 8th grader. Great job Tucker.

  11. Pingback: SportsRighting.com: Launching January 1st, 2013 « Sports Righting

  12. cars says:

    It should be fun to buy a new car! Driving a new car is such a
    great experience, and purchasing the car should be fun as well.

    A lot of people would rather skip the whole purchasing
    process. Keep the stress to a minimum using these tips.

  13. Do you wish to know the best way to use gain
    dish soap coupons? Utilizing gain coupons successfully can help
    you save a lot of your budget. Read the following article to locate great ideas that can aid you use gain coupons and save probably the
    most funds possible.

  14. Hi, after reading this remarkable article i am as well delighted to share
    my experience here with mates.

  15. procera says:

    Memory loss is actually a extremely common cognitive issue among
    the most prevalent problems facing adults as they age. This could bring emotional distress together with
    depression each for the individual suffering and family members and buddies.
    The following suggestions will make it less difficult to deal with memory loss.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s